Previous judges, industry, and patrons included:

Aaron Spina: HBO
Adam Ullian: AdamCentric
Al Martin: Broadway Comedy Club (New York, NY)
Alan Krawitz: Queens Chronicle
Allison Cohn: Allison Cohn Casting
Amy Ambrosino: AM Ambrosino Development & Management
Andrew Unger: Magooby's Joke House (Baltimore, MD)
Angie Frissore: Boston Comedy Scene Examiner
Ann Maney: Nick Mom
Anthony Lane: Planet Gemini (Monterey, CA)
Bob Angeli: Comedy Factory (Edmonton, AB)
Boone Helm: Parlour Live! (Seattle, WA)
Brian Baldinger: New York Comedy Festival
Carol Pennington: Hysterical Management
Chris Bowers: Mortys' Comedy Joint (Indianapolis, IN)
Chris Cotton: Center City Comedy (Philadelphia, PA)
Dan Balassone: On That Note Entertainment
Danielle Ostroske: WeTV
Darrell Holladay: Comedy Caravan (Louisville, KY)
Debbie Feinson: Horizon Entertainment
Dee Mura: Dee Mura Enterprises
Dixie Laite: TeenNick
Elizabeth Wylde: Dells Comedy Club (Wisconsin Dells, WI)
Eric Yoder: Funny Business
Gabe Waldman: Standup NY (New York, NY)
GG Gregg: GG Greg Agency
Heather Barbieri: Rooster T. Feathers (Sunnyvale, CA)
Ian Arougheti: Innovative Artists
Jamison Yoder: Funny Business
Jan Smith: Ice House (Pasadena, CA)
Jim Oliver: William Morris Endeavor
Joe Eshenbaugh: Innovative Artists
John Yoder: Funny Business
Josh Ames: Sashkeen (Manchester, NH)
Justin Prager: Music Choice
Kelly Brennan: Cagneys Pub (Quincy, MA)
Kimiko Nakamura: Dee Mura Enterprises
Larry Getlen: Journalist
Larry Weaver: Larry Weaver Entertainment
Leslie Kappes: The Comedy Club of the Outer Banks
Linda Rohe: Coastal Entertainment
Lisa Lawrence: Headline Talent
Lorraine Kaczorowski: Top Draw Entertainment
Marc Feinson: Horizon Entertainment
Maria Hubbard: Fox
Marianne Ways: Bonnaroo
Marnie Fish: MTV
Marshall Chiles: Laughing Skull Comedy Lounge (Atlanta, GA)
Marty Dundics: National Lampoon
Mary Lindsey: Jokes and Notes (Chicago, IL)
MaryAnn Pierro: The Comic Bible
Maureen Taran: New Wave Entertainment
Natalie Wall: Photographer
Nick Vaden: Higher Ground (Burlington, VT)
Nicole Potter: Films in Review
Randy Butler: Mother Leeds
Renee Fandt: Tacoma Comedy Club (Tacoma, WA)
Rick Morgan: Rick Morgan Agency
Robert Steen: Rent A Comic (Booking Agency)
Roger Paul: Roger Paul Management
Rueben Buck: Parlour Live! (Seattle, WA)
Samantha Lee: TruTV
Samara Palubiski: Turner Talent Network
Steve Hofstetter: Laughs (FOX)
Stu Golfman: AEF Talent
Terry Hollas: Comedy Cave (Calgary, AB)
Todd Pinelli: The Rivoli (Toronto, ON)
Troy Robinson: Mick's Lounge (Stafford, VA)